| Playoffs | Toilet Bowl | |||||||
| (9-5) | 2000 | (4-10) | 2000 | |||||
| #4 Day's Destroyers 33 | #11 Vikaneers 31 | |||||||
| (7-7) | #4 Day's Destroyers 19 | (5-9) | #11 Vikaneers 13 | |||||
| #5 Wolf Pack 18 | (13-1) | Codebreakers 31 | #10 Willard Grid Rats 12 | (6-7-1) | Conder Mints 26 | |||
| (8-6) | #1 Codebreakers 21 | (4-10) | #7 Conder Mints 35 | |||||
| #3 DA's Prosecutors 45 | Wiley's Coyotes! | #12 Steelkings 32 | Steelkings | |||||
| (6-7-1) OT | #3 DA's Prosecutors 16 | Fantasy Bowl XVI | (5-8-1) | #12 Steelkings 39 | Toilet Bowl II | |||
| #6 Bearcats 36 | (9-4-1) | Wiley's Coyotes 39 | #9 Daun's Demons 27 | (6-8) | Steelkings 40 | |||
| #2 Wiley's Coyotes 29 | 2000 | #8 Cranium Morbus 26 | ||||||
| Day's Destroyers 17 | Vikaneers 30 | |||||||
| DA's Prosecutors | Vikaneers | |||||||
| DA's Prosecutors 35 | 3rd place | Cranium Morbus 28 | 9th place | |||||
| #5 Wolf Pack 7 | #10 Willard Grid Rats 4 | |||||||
| Bearcats | Daun's Demons | |||||||
| #6 Bearcats 30 | 5th place | #9 Daun's Demons 25 | 11th place | |||||
| (10-4) | 1999 | (6-8) | 1999 | |||||
| #4 Day's Destroyers 24 | #9 Spider Web 17 | |||||||
| (7-7) | Willard Grid Rats 25 | (4-10) | Bone Crushers 25 | |||||
| #5 Willard Grid Rats 25 | (10-4) | Willard Grid Rats 28 | #12 Bone Crushers 21 | (6-8) | Bone Crushers 25 | |||
| (6-7-1) | #1 Vikaneers 20 | (6-8) | #8 Wiley's Coyotes 23 | |||||
| #6 DA's Prosecutors 18 | Willard Grid Rats! | #10 Codebreakers 18 | Bone Crushers | |||||
| (7-7) | DA's Prosecutors 35 | Fantasy Bowl XV | (6-8) | Conder Mints 20 | Toilet Bowl I | |||
| #3 Daun's Demons 15 | (9-5) | DA's Prosecutors 27 | #11 Conder Mints 30 | (6-7-1) | Conder Mints 15 | |||
| #2 Bearcats 20 | 1999 | #7 Wolf Pack 13 | ||||||
| Bearcats 23 | Wolf Pack 16 | |||||||
| Bearcats | Wiley's Coyotes | |||||||
| Vikaneers 21 | 3rd place | Wiley's Coyotes 32 | 9th place | |||||
| Daun's Demons 8 | Spider Web 29 | |||||||
| Day's Destroyers | Spider Web | |||||||
| Day's Destroyers 26 | 5th place | Codebreakers 19 | 11th place | |||||
| (8-6) | 1998 | |||||||
| #5 Wolf Pack 29 | #7 Willard Grid Rats (7-7) | |||||||
| (9-5) | Wolf Pack | #8 Bearcats (6-8) | ||||||
| #4 Conder Mints 28 | (9-4-1) | Vikaneers 29 | #9 Wiley's Coyotes (5-9) | |||||
| (9-5) | #1 Vikaneers | #10 Bone Crushers (5-9) | ||||||
| #3 DA's Prosecutors 38 | Codebreakers! | #11 Daun's Guns (4-9-1) | ||||||
| (7-6-1) | Codebreakers | Fantasy Bowl XIV | #12 Day's Destroyers (4-9-1) | |||||
| #6 Codebreakers 40 | (9-5) | Codebreakers 40 | ||||||
| #2 Spider Web | ||||||||
| (7-7) | 1997 | |||||||
| #5 Day's Destroyers 23 | #7 Holy Moellers (7-7) | |||||||
| (8-6) | Day's Destroyers 34 | #8 Steelkings (6-8) | ||||||
| #4 Bearcats 6 | (13-1) | Day's Destroyers 12 | #9 Conder Mints (6-8) | |||||
| (7-7) | #1 Willard Grid Rats 24 | #10 Weller's Fellers (6-8) | ||||||
| #3 Chester's Champs 20 | Bone Crushers! | #11 DA's Prosecutors (5-9) | ||||||
| (7-7) | Chester's Champs 9 | Fantasy Bowl XIII | #12 Wolf Pack (2-12) | |||||
| #6 Wiley's Coyotes 18 | (10-4) | Bone Crushers 20 | ||||||
| #2 Bone Crushers 18 | ||||||||
| (8-5-1) | 1996 | |||||||
| #5 Weller's Fellers 21 | #7 Chester's Champs (7-6-1) | |||||||
| (9-5) | Weller's Fellers 21 | #8 Delta Dawns (5-8-1) | ||||||
| #4 Willard Grid Rats 16 | (9-4-1) | Weller's Fellers 19 | #9 Steelkings (5-9) | |||||
| (6-4-4) | #1 Day's Destroyers 17 | #10 Wiley's Coyotes (5-9) | ||||||
| #3 Wolf Pack 18 | Conder Mints!! | #11 DA's Prosecutors (4-9-1) | ||||||
| (7-6-1) | Conder Mints 19 | Fantasy Bowl XII | #12 Biomet Broncos (4-9-1) | |||||
| #6 Conder Mints 22 | (9-4-1) | Conder Mints 28 | ||||||
| #2 Ford's Follies 18 | ||||||||
| (8-6) | 1995 | |||||||
| #5 Bone Crushers 21 | #7 Wolf Pack (7-7) | |||||||
| (8-5-1) | Chester's Champs 20 | #8 Day's Destroyers (5-7-2) | ||||||
| #4 Chester's Champs 22 | (13-1) | Willard Grid Rats 28 | #9 DA's Prosecutors (6-8) | |||||
| (9-4-1) | #1 Willard Grid Rats 50 | #10 Biomet Broncos (4-10) | ||||||
| #3 Weller's Fellers 24 | Conder Mints! | #11 Osteonics Outlaws (1-11-2) | ||||||
| (7-7) | Wiley's Coyotes 28 | Fantasy Bowl XI | #12 Ford's Follies (2-12) | |||||
| #6 Wiley's Coyotes 28 | (11-3) | Conder Mints 31 | ||||||
| #2 Conder Mints 51 | ||||||||
| (8-6) | 1994 | |||||||
| #5 Wolf Pack 8 | #7 Horner's Coroners (8-6) | |||||||
| (9-5) | Wiley's Coyotes 8 | #8 Day's Destroyers (7-7) | ||||||
| #4 Wiley's Coyotes 12 | (9-5) | Roadrunners 17 | #9 Holy Moellers (7-7) | |||||
| (8-6) | #1 Roadrunners 25 | #10 Willard Grid Rats (5-9) | ||||||
| #3 Bone Crushers 26 | Roadrunners! | #11 Ramsey's Regulators (4-10) | ||||||
| (8-6) | Bone Crushers 13 | Fantasy Bowl X | #12 Weller's Fellers (2-12) | |||||
| #6 Conder Mints 13 | (9-5) | Bone Crushers 7 | ||||||
| #2 Biomet Broncos 5 | ||||||||
| (9-6) | 1993 | |||||||
| #5 Conder Mints 7 | #7 Holy Moellers (7-8) | |||||||
| (9-6) | Bone Crushers 25 | #8 Horner's Coroners (6-8-1) | ||||||
| #4 Bone Crushers 49 | (11-4) | Bone Crushers 13 | #9 Weller's Fellers (6-9) | |||||
| (9-6) | #1 Regulators 13 | #10 Chester's Champs (6-9) | ||||||
| #3 Chief Wahoos 21 | Wolf Pack! | #11 Willard Grid Rats (5-10) | ||||||
| (7-8) | Wolf Pack 18 | Fantasy Bowl IX | #12 Day's Destroyers (4-10-1) | |||||
| #6 Wolf Pack 28 | (10-5) | Wolf Pack 25 | ||||||
| #2 Wiley's Coyotes 7 | ||||||||
| (8 - 5 - 1) | 1992 | |||||||
| #5 Willard Grid Rats 11 | #7 Horner's Coroners (7-7) | |||||||
| (9 - 5) | Holy Moellers 15 | #8 Chester's Champs (5-8-1) | ||||||
| #4 Holy Moellers 30 | (11 - 3) | Bone Crushers 10 | #9 Conder Mints (4-8-2) | |||||
| (9 - 4 - 1) | #1 Bone Crushers 25 | #10 Hill-Billys (5-9) | ||||||
| #3 Ramsey's Regulators12 | Weller's Fellers! | #11 Flying Burritos (4-10) | ||||||
| (7 - 7) | Wileys' Coyotes 8 | Fantasy Bowl VIII | #12 Wolf Pack (3-11) | |||||
| #6 Wiley's Coyotes 26 | (9 - 4 - 1) | Weller's Fellers 12 | ||||||
| #2 Weller's Fellers 27 | ||||||||
| (8-6) | 1991 | |||||||
| #5 Bone Crushers 14 | #7 Holy Moellers (6-6-2) | |||||||
| (9-4-1) | Willard Grid Rats 12 | #8 Kilowatts (5-7-2) | ||||||
| #4 Willard Grid Rats 20 | (11-3) | Wolf Pack 14 | #9 Weller's Fellers (5-9) | |||||
| (7-6-1) | #1 Wolf Pack 26 | #10 Ramsey's Regulators (4-9-1) | ||||||
| #6 Conder Mints 26 | Conder Mints! | #11 Wiley's Coyotes (3-9-2) | ||||||
| (8-6) | Conder Mints 22 | Fantasy Bowl VII | #12 T & M Truckers (3-11) | |||||
| #3 Hill Billy's 21 | (10-3-1) | Conder Mints 31 | ||||||
| #2 Horner's Coroners 4 | ||||||||
| (9-5) | 1990 | |||||||
| #4 Weller's Fellers 7 | #7 Busco Wankers (7-7) | |||||||
| (9-5) | Holy Moellers 25 | #8 Willard Grid Rats (6-8) | ||||||
| #5 Holy Moellers 23 | (9-5) | Horner's Coroners 16 | #9 Wiley's Coyotes (5-8-1) | |||||
| (7-7) | #1 Horner's Coroners 36 | #10 Ramsey's Regulators (5-9) | ||||||
| #3 Bone Crushers 19 | Bone Crushers! | #11 Bartolowits & Jaymes (5-9) | ||||||
| (8-6) | Bone Crushers 36 | Fantasy Bowl VI | #12 Hackin' Kaufman (4-9-1) | |||||
| #6 Wolf Pack 15 | (9-5) | Bone Crushers 21 | ||||||
| #2 Coram Legion 14 | ||||||||
| (6-5-2) | 1989 | |||||||
| #5 Willard Grid Rats 19 | #7 Ramsey's Regulators (6-6-1) | |||||||
| (7-6) | Willard Grid Rats 13 | #8 Kelly's Heroes (5-5-3) | ||||||
| #4 Bone Crushers 12 | (8-4-1) | Wolf Pack 21 | #9 Snap-on Tuley's (5-6-2) | |||||
| (8-5) | #1 Wolf Pack 19 | #10 Brehob Goblins (5-7-1) | ||||||
| #3 Frederick's of 19 | Wally's Gators! | #11 Scott's Towels (4-9) | ||||||
| Hollywood | Weller's Fellers 13 | Fantasy Bowl V | #12 Richmond Virgins (3-8-2) | |||||
| (6-5-2) | (8-5) | Wally's Gators 44 | ||||||
| #6 Weller's Fellers 23 | ||||||||
| #2 Wally's Gators 43 | ||||||||
| (6-7) | 1988 | |||||||
| #5 Weller's Fellers 20 | #7 Wolf Pack (5-7-1) | |||||||
| (8-5) | Brehob Goblins 18 | #8 Fredericks of Hollywood (5-7-1) | ||||||
| #4 Brehob Goblins 26 | (11-2) | Kelly's Heroes 16 | #9 Tuley's Mechanics (4-8-1) | |||||
| (8-5) | #1 Kelly's Heroes 27 | #10 Temple of Doom (4-9) | ||||||
| #3 Ramsey's Regulators22 | Willard Grid Rats! | #11 Richmond Virgins (4-9) | ||||||
| (6-7) | Ramsey's Regulators 29 | Fantasy Bowl IV | ||||||
| #6 Wally's Gators 12 | (8-5) | Willard Grid Rats 29 | ||||||
| #2 Willard Grid Rats 47 | ||||||||
| (5-4) | 1987 | |||||||
| #5 Wally's Gators 27 | #7 Banks' Federals (3-6) | |||||||
| (5-4) | Kielbassy Kids 25 | #8 Willard Grid Rats (3-6) | ||||||
| #4 Kielbassy Kids 33 | (8-1) | Temple of Doom 26 | #9 Susan's Sloths (3-6) | |||||
| (6-3) | #1 Temple of Doom 42 | #10 Brehob Goblins (2-7) | ||||||
| #3 Richmond Virgins 24 | Temple of Doom!! | #11 Anderson Indians (1-8) | ||||||
| (4-5) | Richmond Virgins 44 | Fantasy Bowl III | ||||||
| #6 Snap-on Tuley's 12 | (7-2) | Richmond Virgins 18 | ||||||
| #2 Wolf Pack 23 | ||||||||
| (7-6) | 1986 | |||||||
| #5 Banks' Federals 26 | #7 Stidham's Steeds (4-8-1) | |||||||
| (8-5) | Banks' Federals 27 | #8 Willard Grid Rats (4-9) | ||||||
| #4 Snap-on Tuley's 20 | (9-3-1) | Banks' Federals 16 | #9 Auto-Mattick (3-10) | |||||
| (10-3) | #2 Anderson Indians 18 | #10 McFarland Away (2-11) | ||||||
| #3 Richmond Virgins 12 | Temple of Doom! | |||||||
| (5-8) | Wolf Pack 29 | Fantasy Bowl II | ||||||
| #6 Wolf Pack 22 | (12-1) | Temple of Doom 29 | ||||||
| #1 Temple of Doom 47 | ||||||||
| 1985 | ||||||||
| (6-3-1) | #5 Banks' Federals (5-5) | |||||||
| #2 Ford's Follies 22 | #6 Un-Suterble (4-6) | |||||||
| (6-4) | Anderson Indians 19 | #7 Frank's Beans (3-6-1) | ||||||
| #3 Anderson Indians 32 | #8 Tuley's Mechanics (3-7) | |||||||
| (5-5) | Willard Grid Rats! | |||||||
| #4 Willard Grid Rats 21 | Fantasy Bowl I | |||||||
| (7-3) | Willard Grid Rats 24 | |||||||
| #1 Wolf Pack 17 | ||||||||